Cue JAWS music…
When deciding what to take for our Jimmy Buffett tailgating experience, I of course thought of making cupcakes! I made the Margarita cupcakes but also wanted something more traditional… I saw a picture of some beach and shark cupcakes and thought they were really cute and very fitting.
As usual, when I make more than 1 kind of recipe, I make one from scratch and one from a box. I made the margarita cupcakes from scratch and used the WW Diet Coke method on these babies.
1 box cake mix – I used Devil’s Food
1 can of diet coke – any variety will do – I used Diet Dr Pepper
1 egg white (to help hold it all together)
Follow directions on box for cake or cupcakes except use only ingredients listed above.
I used store bought frosting that and dyed it blue.








I am Jen the Beantown Baker. Engineer by day and baking maven by night. Hubby serves as my #1 fan and official taste tester. We got hitched back in 2006. Barefoot. In the sand. With the waves crashing behind us. It was one of the best decisions we’ve ever made. 






I’m sold fuggy chocolately cookies sound amazing
They look so cute, I have yet to try the candy cane kisses.
How cute! I love those candy cane kisses!
I love how the red stripes stay pretty in tact after melting! Looks fabulously festive 🙂
Yea, we really like the candy cane kisses. They have little bits of candy cane in them so there’s a tiny bit of crunch.
Jen- they look great! I love your stripes- THey look so pretty!
I think these were my favorites looking back.
When do you add the vanilla extract? :oP
Thanks for pointing that out Jamie. I updated the recipe. You add the vanilla after the eggs.